By Theodore (Ted) Byrer, Independent Insurance Agent and Certified Annuity Specialist® (CAS®) · Westfield, Indiana · November 2026

Record demand for guarantees: what the latest annuity sales numbers say about retirement worries

Annuity sales just set another quarterly record. Here's what the numbers show, why so many retirees are looking for guarantees, and why a record for the industry says nothing about whether an annuity fits you.

Every few months, a new set of industry numbers lands, and this fall's were hard to miss.  According to preliminary results LIMRA released on November 6, 2026, total U.S. annuity sales rose 4% year over year to a record $126.3 billion in the third quarter of 2026.  It was the 12th consecutive quarter of more than $100 billion in sales.  Year to date, total annuity sales reached $355.0 billion.

I'm Ted Byrer, and I help people in Westfield and across Hamilton County think through how their savings will turn into income.  Numbers like these are worth understanding.  They are not a reason, by themselves, to buy anything.

What the record annuity sales numbers show

LIMRA's survey represents 93% of the U.S. annuity market, and the figures are preliminary, so they can be revised.  Two of the categories it reports are the ones I work with most:

  • Fixed-rate deferred annuities: $44.5 billion in the third quarter, up 7% from the second quarter and 2% higher than a year earlier.  This category includes multi-year guaranteed annuities (MYGAs), which credit a set interest rate for a set number of years.
  • Fixed indexed annuities (FIAs): $30.7 billion in the third quarter, level with the second quarter and 8% lower than a year earlier.

LIMRA pointed to higher crediting rates after the Federal Reserve's September rate increase as one reason fixed-rate deferred sales rose.  It also noted that FIA sales had not yet picked up from that rate change.  So the record is not one smooth wave.  Different contracts respond to rates in different ways, and that's one more reason to compare the details rather than follow the headline.

One more fine-print item: LIMRA updated its sales definition starting with its January 2026 report, and sales now include money paid into existing contracts and certain internal exchanges.  Keep that in mind when comparing this year's figures to older ones.

Source: LIMRA, "U.S. Annuity Sales Set New Quarterly Record, Totaling $126.3 Billion in the Third Quarter of 2026," November 6, 2026

Why so many retirees want guarantees

Sales figures don't explain themselves, but the conversations I have at kitchen tables across Hamilton County point to the same four worries again and again.

Living a long time. Retirement can last 25 or 30 years.  Nobody knows how long their own will run, and savings that have to stretch for an unknown number of years can make every withdrawal feel like a guess.  Income an insurance company promises to pay for life takes part of that guess off the table.

A market downturn early in retirement. A drop in the market is hard at any age.  It is hardest in the first few years after you stop working, when you're also taking money out.  Selling during a downturn to pay the bills can leave less to recover when things improve.  Many people want part of their money set aside where index declines or market losses won't reduce it.

The pension gap. Many of today's retirees never had a traditional pension.  Social Security covers part of the monthly bills, and savings have to cover the rest.  Some people want to turn part of those savings into the paycheck a pension used to provide.

Predictability. Plenty of retirees tell me they don't need the most money possible.  They want to know what's coming in each month so they can stop checking balances and start living.

How guarantees can work

There are two broad kinds of guarantees people look for, and different contracts handle them differently.

Lifetime income. An immediate or deferred income annuity, or an FIA with an optional lifetime income rider, can provide income for as long as you live, or as long as either spouse lives.  That promise is backed by the financial strength and claims-paying ability of the issuing insurance company.  The bigger picture is on my guaranteed retirement income page.

Protection of principal from market loss. A MYGA credits a guaranteed rate for a set term, so the account value doesn't fall when markets do.  Unlike bank CDs, MYGAs are not FDIC insured, and surrender charges can apply to early withdrawals.  You can compare the two in MYGA rates vs. CDs.  An FIA protects the account value from index declines, and interest can be credited based in part on how an index performs.  Your premium is not placed in the stock market or any index.  Some of the index strategies I work with have no cap and no strategy fee, with a participation rate of 100% or more for the current crediting term.  That does not mean you get the stock market's return.  Credits follow the strategy's index, which may be designed to limit swings, and the insurer can change crediting terms at each renewal.  Interest credits can be zero in some years, and index credits do not include dividends.  More on how they work is on my fixed indexed annuities page.

Either way, these guarantees come with tradeoffs.  Surrender charges and a market value adjustment (MVA) can apply if you take out more than the contract allows in the early years, and optional riders may carry fees.  Money in an annuity is meant to stay put for a while, so your emergency fund belongs somewhere else.

A quick tax note, kept general: annuity income and withdrawals are generally taxed as ordinary income, and taxable amounts taken before age 59½ may face a 10% federal penalty.  How that applies to you depends on where the money comes from, so consult your tax professional.

A record for the industry isn't a recommendation for you

Billions of dollars moving into annuities tells you that many households want guarantees right now.  It doesn't tell you whether you need one, how much, or which kind.  For some people, Social Security and a pension already cover the bills, and the right answer is to leave things alone.  For others, putting part of their savings, never all of it, toward guaranteed income or principal protection makes the rest of the plan easier to live with.

The way to find out is to start with your own numbers: the monthly bills, the income you already have, and the gap between them.  The retirement paycheck gap tool is a good place to begin.

Frequently asked questions

Annuity sales hit a record.  Does that mean I should buy one?

Not necessarily.  A sales record shows what many households are choosing, not what fits you.  Whether an annuity makes sense depends on your income, your bills, your other savings, and how long you can leave the money in place.

What's the difference between a fixed-rate deferred annuity and a fixed indexed annuity?

A fixed-rate deferred annuity, such as a MYGA, credits a set interest rate for a set term.  A fixed indexed annuity credits interest based in part on how an index performs, with the account value protected from index declines.  Interest credits can be zero in some years.

Can an annuity lose value in a market downturn?

A MYGA or FIA account value does not go down because the market or an index goes down.  Withdrawals, rider fees, surrender charges, and an MVA can still reduce it.  Guarantees are backed by the financial strength and claims-paying ability of the issuing insurance company.

How do we meet, and what does a review cost?

We can talk by phone, by video, or at your home.  The review is complimentary, and there is no obligation.  I'm paid by the insurance company if a contract is placed, and any rider fees and surrender charges are spelled out in the contract before you sign.

Related reading

Want to see where you stand?

If you'd like to look at your own gap between income and bills, I'll lay out the options side by side, including the option of doing nothing.  The review is complimentary, comes with no obligation, and takes place by phone, by video, or at your home, whichever is easiest for you.

Call 317-900-6970 or email ted@byrerwealth.com.

Ted Byrer · Independent Insurance Agent · Certified Annuity Specialist® (CAS®) · Retirement Income Specialist

Byrer Wealth Management, LLC · Westfield, Indiana

317-900-6970 · ted@byrerwealth.com

Meetings are by phone, by video, or at your home.

Important information: This page is education, not a recommendation of any specific product, and it is not tax or legal advice.  Sales figures are preliminary industry estimates from LIMRA, dated November 6, 2026, and may be revised.  Ted Byrer and Byrer Wealth Management, LLC are not affiliated with or endorsed by LIMRA.  Annuities are insurance contracts issued by insurance companies.  They are not deposits, are not FDIC or NCUA insured, and are not guaranteed by any bank or government agency.  Guarantees are backed by the financial strength and claims-paying ability of the issuing insurance company.  Annuities are subject to contract terms, and features vary by contract and state.  Surrender charges and a market value adjustment (MVA) may apply to early withdrawals.  Rider fees may apply.  Annuity income and withdrawals are generally taxed as ordinary income: all of it for IRA or other pre-tax money, and the gain for non-qualified money.  Taxable amounts taken before age 59½ may be subject to a 10% federal tax penalty.  A fixed indexed annuity does not participate directly in the stock market or any index; interest credits can be zero in some years, and index credits exclude dividends.  CAS® is an annuity designation and a registered trademark of the Institute of Business & Finance.  The designation does not mean IBF endorses Byrer Wealth Management, LLC or any product.  Ted Byrer offers insurance products only.  He is not a registered investment adviser, broker-dealer, or bank, and does not offer securities.

Indiana Resident Insurance Producer License #2767910 · NPN 1498594

Ready to talk this through?

A no-cost, no-obligation conversation with Ted Byrer.

Start a conversation